Wednesday, February 19, 2014

History of Transgender

Ask most people that know what it means to be transgender (small number sadly) when the first cases appeared most will answer 1952 with Christen Jorgenson!

(even GLADD  puts it this way and they are wrong)  

And they would greatly be Wrong. Heck not even close to the date and the first cases. So this month’s issue on hand I will be discussing several of the lost moments in history and even introduce you to a subject that had been part of the world since the invention of writing.  

When we look at this issue I do want to state one thing while some on this list will be simply transvestites (otherwise known as cross dressers) Others are in fact Trangender we know this by not only how they acted but thru their actions in history. This is a new subject for this blog even though I had been studying this for well 3 three years now I may still be a bit off on my research but please bear with me on this one.

The first recorded Trans person!
Hatshepsut The female emperor of Egypt - 1479 -1458 BC

Okay one may state I am stretching on this but not really it is down to the wording that Hatshepsut refused the title of Empress for the term Emperor instead. Upon her accenting to the royal throne she dawn a false beard and male clothing. Her reign is mostly wiped from history because her son ordered the destruction of her image when he rose to power. Despite the fact that she was in many ways the only pharaoh to accomplish and see thru her projects in her lifetime as ruler. It’s not fully known on how she was treated in court but for a woman to even seat on the royal throne at these times was unheard of and she stands as one of Egypt’s strongest rulers.

The Man-woman of Emperor of Rome
Emperor Elgabalus - 203 – 222 AD

I use the term Man-woman as it’s a medical term that Romans first discovered some point between the 6th and 1st century BC, and several years after they found the basis of trans-genderism in their medical studies a transgender emperor rose to power. Now Elgabalus was not a great emperor, just the opposite in fact many place him in second worst behind Caligula. And the fact that the only really thing of note about him was the way he presented himself in female clothing and acting female in many cases committing perverted acts and prostitution, he even offered a reward for the doctor willing to perform early days sex change surgery at a time when the first plastic surgeries where a death sentence for those that underwent them from the diseases and complications that the surgery would cause. The reward was never claimed. It is important to note that the court was use to Eldabalus actions after Nero took a Eunuch named Sporus as a wife and was displayed in the royal garb of an empress in 60 AD.

The Big Apple’s Big Secret, That No one Wanted
This is said to be a picture of him but is likely his wife

Edward Hyde - 1661 – 1723
In many ways Edward was the worst Governor ever placed in office while England ruled over the colonies. A lord through birthright Edward, was not well liked and massively corrupt  but still he sat in as one of New York and New Jersey’s first governor s.  Robbing the colonies treasury and harassing the public as he dawned woman’s clothing and acted as an outright public menace. He was removed from office after creating so much a stink with the public that the revolution may have occurred years earlier if he hadn’t been removed.

 The First to stand up as Trans
Charlotte Clark - 1755
She is the one in Pink

The first recorded Transgender and lesbian person as when the book “A Narrative of the life of Mrs. Charlotte Clark” An autobiography told the story of the cross dressing actress during a time that even the concept of women being on stage was unheard of. She spoke of her relationship with a woman only known as Ms. Brown and sadly while the publication brought her fame in her lifetime she died penniless and destitute. Sadly not much is known of this early figure in history and even rarer is it likely to find a copy of her autobiography but luckily we now have the internet and Wikipedia has a nice entry on her life and writings

World’s Greatest Spy
D’eon De Beaumont - 1777

Now we really have a pivotal figure that far too often is ignored in history. Now I could have placed the first strong case as Joan of Arc she wasn’t hiding her gender for anything more then to join the battle. Instead we have someone living both genders and even persecuted for it.  D’eon is known as one of the greatest spies not just in his time but ever. Here is a list of just some of his known accomplishments covers and encounters.

even in that dress D'eon could kick major butt


Skilled Dragoon of French royal court (Royal knight)
Lady in waiting to Catharine the Great (Yes the Russian queen famous for rumors her equestrian encounters)
Friend of Queen Charlotte (wife of George the 3rd aka Mad King George)
One of the greatest swords man in France at the time
Rumored friend/chess player and supporter of Benjamin Franklin

D’eon in his efforts as a spy used a genetic disorder (Klinefelter’s Syndrome) to his advantage and dawn the disguise as Lady Lea De Beaumont. Despite the skill and continued loyalty to the crown King Louis the 16th upon gaining the throne from his father Louis the 15th, forced D’eon to dress and act as a lady in court because of the treatment of ladies versus lords when it came time for the American revolution D’eon wanted to go forth and honor France and fight on the side of the Americans only the King felt it was an insult to have a woman represent France and had D’eon exiled to of all places England for even daring to help. D’eon spent his last days in England as an ambassador and friend of the royal court. 

Despite the added zombies it is an awesome anime and one of my favorites of all time its both very artistic and intense drama. Check it out its on Netflix or buy the series now from Funimation


Now it is important to note not all history has washed D’eon away as in 2006 a manga and anime series was made loosely based on his life (very loosely but it’s really good as a supernatural horror)  


And then there was the word
Karl Friedrich Otto Westphal - 1869
The term Transexualism is officially coined by Karl in his medical paper where he simply diagnosed the symptoms of men wanting to be women; it is his paper that would be the earliest medical study on the issue. More words would come such as 1910 Marcus Hirschfield coining the term “Transvestite” while he and Harry Benjamin where researching since 1907. The first use of the word “Faggot” appearing in a Portland Oregon dictionary in 1914 putting all LBGT issues under its terminology

Doctor of Sex
Marcus Hirschfeild - 1919

After almost 20 years of his course of study the subject Marcus opened the Institute for Sexology, in Berlin. In it he worked to study transsexuals in particular to further his research. In one case of study a successful transplant of sexual organs occurred (yeah I bet you think it never could happen) sadly while the surgery was considered a success the patient died of internal bleeding the day after, the process to medical knowledge has never been tried again. The first successful surgeries afterwards as we now know them started the next year.

Literature gets twisted  
Virginia Woolf Writes “Orlando” - 1928
Famed female writer tells her tale of a man that refuses to grow old and one day awakens to having changed genders then goes on living as a woman. Keep in mind this was written at the High point of Victorian living where the idea of any sexual behavior is considered wrong and yet here was a book purposing the twisted concepts of sexual escapades of both man in woman in one character.

First Child Treatment
Harry Benjamin -1948
Harry who co-founded of the study of Transexualism was introduced to a young boy that wanted to transition. The practice up until then had been strictly done with adults but after study of the boy Harry started the treatments on the boy in San Francisco (4 years before Christen Jorgenson became the face of transsexuals) This caused Benjamin to open the first clinic for Transgender patients in the US.

Give Him Meat and two Veg
Matt Dillon – 1949
The first recorded Female to Male transition occurs, transitioning Matt in London England. It took him 13 surgeries to get the completion he so wanted to live out his time as a man.

A Star Rises
Christen Jorgenson -1952


While the practice was becoming a common thing for treatment up until Christen it hasn’t really been a public issue. When the New York Daily News made world news with the transition of the former soldier and photographer showed the world sometime that sexy blond bomb shell may have been playing on a different team in childhood.  While this Wikipedia article is somewhat good about the story I strongly suggest a surprising film of its time The Christen Jorgenson Story 1970.

The Worst Director, Shows the world
Ed Wood Jr., releases Glen or Glenda   - 1953
Sadly despite being labeled the worst director of all time this really is a good film and very sincere all be it still with its issues as Ed Wood tried to give a face on the issue that he himself was dealing with. Given the later Tim Burton film on Ed Wood would ignore Glen or Glenda but still touched on Ed’s love for dressing. Ed Wood never stated on if it was inspired by Christen Jorgenson or not but it’s believed it was his reasoning for making the film. Much of Ed’s usual actors where in this film including Horror Film Legend Bella Lugosi giving an odd moment in the film where he makes the whole process seem dark.
Watch the whole film on Youtube

The Rocket is complete
Dr. Judy T Wu – 1958
Dr Wu creates the first complete Phalloplasty surgery changing the way the surgery for FtM patients were going through.   Oddly enough I really want to emphases the location this occurred was Bratsk, Russia. Yeah the same place that lately has gone anti LGBT severally is the home of one of the modern procedures in transgender surgery. It was Wu that devised a way for the new member to stand erect as well.
I could go on from here but then the History from 1960 to modern times is well covered and described in many other sources including GLADD and other places. I do want to note though a few rumors and issues not confined to History

To defend and Honor (All Known Wars before 1950’s)
While there are many cases including my choice to ignore Joan of Arc, we should not ignore the fact that many women served in wars worldwide even to the point of arrest, execution (in Joan’s Case) and exile should they be found out.  They would dawn disguises and false names till they were found out in battle, such figures like Deborah Sampson in the Revolution or Sarah Rosetta Wakeman/ Private Lyons Wakeman.  They were the first women to serve this nation with honors and integrity yet far too often are ignored by history books. While most did it for the cause, others saw it as a chance of equal rights and a few cases it is assumed that they may have seen themselves as men. It is not recorded how many women dawned pants and fought in war some may never have even gone noticed at all, but all are due their respect for their role in history.

Outlaw is Out the closet?
One of the strangest rumors out there is that Billy the Kid (Yes the Billy the Kid) was in fact transgender. In fact there is claimed a rumored image of Billy in drag. Sadly the only real reference to this was an episode of Discovery’s Wild West Tech. It is believe to be nothing more than an attempt to drum up interest in the show.

FBI goes deep under cover?

The Infamous case of J Edgar Hoover is… well completely made up. The issue that Hoover wore women’s clothing and was gay was a rumor started by criminals and the mob in an effort to get Hoover ousted from office. Why? Well how about the fact that the director was biting down hard on the criminal activities of the group. Thus the rumor mill was spilled that J Edgar wore Mrs. Hooves Finest.

Stonewalled
Okay this is the last historical issue I will bring up in this post. The moment Gay rights became an issue was Stonewall riots. And the spark that lit that fuse was the arrest of transgender individuals. Every point of the GLBT civil rights began with transgender people and I bring this up as it’s become somewhat an ignored issue of the last few years that the GLB have gained rights that the T still face prosecution about things like finding work and places to live still are issues for the trans community that the LGB end rarely if ever face. In many ways I see it as a disgrace to have the LGB culture to run to the front of the line and step over the equal rights of the people that helped give them a voice in gaining their own rights. But then we are starting to see a change in these rules and laws as we grow and soon I truly hope that we can say Justice is blind and 
ALL are treated equally.

Additional Supporting links on this subject

Thank you for sitting down to this massive chunk of trans history. If I missed something or you want to share something then leave a comment, if you don’t feel like making it public email me at brittanydodson@imbriaarts.com. This is intended as a public discussion not just a blog. I would like to thank all that have sent me messages of support for both your families and myself in this discussion. I am sorry I try to respond to all but sometimes I just feel there is little more I can add to your heart felt letters then a loving Thank you.

Next Month’s Subject: 
 Who will Stand Above!
 We look at Trans voices and see if we can find strong voices as well as discuss issues about civil rights and discrimination (using both sides of the arguments) expect it to get heated on this one.

Suggested Homework:
Okay I didn’t do this the first time on the new blog or in the special after but the original path offered tasks and projects people can do with each lesson so I am going to try to have such tasks again from now on. I will go into more when I get to truly discussing the process of transitioning but for now here is this month’s discussions homework.

Read History books and go to history museums- Yeah I am copping out but seriously when we have a recent study say 1 in 4 Americans think the sun revolves around the earth this is an important homework, the subject doesn’t have to be about trans characters but it can be. There are many I know I left out of discussion for frankly space. I personally live in a part of the US where you can’t spit and not hit some place of historic importance of this county (I live in Richmond VA USA) Learn your own history of your family or just catch up on historical people who changed the world

Trans in the News Issue:
Facebook adds new classification of genders for members to choose from.
Now damned if you do damned if you don’t, it’s a mixed bag. I know many trans people that aren’t changing their status for the fear of repercussions of labeling themselves on Facebook. Me personally I don’t care. I changed my status last week from female (what I had it as before) to Trans female. I do not fear the world being open about myself and even apply as such and am open about it when I talk with others. It’s all about personal choice but just to be fair about the issue here is an article about a comedians report on the matter. (And for those that take Colbert as a reporter I feel sorry for you. He is a comedian not a reporter. Don’t ever take him or John Stewart as actual news authorities on any subject they are there to make you laugh at subjects don’t take them seriously ever.)


Sunday, February 2, 2014

Path Special: Why cant Hollywood hire trans actors?

Okay from time to time when I feel its appropriate to address an issue I will be adding special reports and opinion based pieces. This is not February’s discussion but a discussion on an important issue none the less. So onto the subject at hand.

While sitting back and doing some research as my laundry was running in the background I came across this news article from the UK.


Basically the article asks the question why Hollywood doesn’t hire trans actors for trans roles. For this I have a few things to say that doesn’t quite fit in the comments box so I am bringing the discussion over here.
When one looks at the collection of trans characters in film we often see one of two ways Hollywood attacks them. Ether you have a male actor play out the role with latex and padding to play the role in a dress (or binding of female actors in the case of trans men) to present a buyable transformation or they go with a female actor playing a trans woman, or a male actor playing a trans man. There are many reasons for and even a few that people don’t look at when discussing this issue.  But the idea that trans actors don’t play trans characters isn’t true. Given its rare in its occurrence Candis Cayne being probably the best to fit this role in a serious tone. While there are several Trans people in Hollywood she is likely the only solid actress / actor that has come out as trans that has had somewhat steady work and played roles like her roles in the tv show Dirty Sexy Money as a trans character.

Candis Cayne

When we seriously look at the issue the main problem is the numbers. If you take 1000 people and claim that within that collection that 10% will become actors dropping the choice to 100 people then out of that 10% of them would likely be successful giving us now 10 people the chances of those 10 people being just gay is 1/10 being trans is 1/30 so the chance is such a smaller fragment. Of having a successful trans actor/ actress is small (note I will not declare reality tv stars as actors as they are not. They are just people wanting to become famous by exposing their lives in form of humiliation.) So given our small fraction we need to add in the factor that people just aren’t discovered that easily and revered for their work. In a world where there are over 3000 television channels on our cable boxes and with it a dwindling fan based of television in general with the continued decreasing numbers of viewers that rather would watch stuff through online content and at their own time, along with it dwindling box office numbers creates a need for stability in Hollywood to look at talent that they know is solid over talent that they question or risk with. Meaning the chance of roles are so rare for trans actors to break through it’s not likely to change in the current path of Hollywood.

Lana Wachowski

Chaz Bono

Alexis Arquette

Now we need to look at the issue in another way. The question really should be reworded. Why do we not have a good example of a transgender person in general.  There are few well know trans gender people that tv and new sources run to when dealing with trans people. Often these days the face has been put on people such as Chaz Bono (the child of Sonny Bono and Cher) and Alexis Arquette (the true black sheep of the Arquette family, bet you thought it was David) , Lana Wachowski (of the Wachowski Brothers [oddly still called that]). These people are held up as the main stream of trans genders but I have to say what have these and others really done to help push transgender people into being successful in the world. Well since coming out Chaz has been a reality Tv star mainly cause of the transition (yet his call to fame is that he is transgender) Has he done much to help others out and lift others up. Nope not really. Alexis is pretty much the same but has mainly gotten her stardom through the fame of her family and played in small roles since. The last Lana is and while she was a big director before the transition (Director/creator of the Matrix series) she hasn’t found much success in her films since her coming out. She carries on her life much in the same way as before. 
 

So what we need to more focus on is who in the trans community is willing to do more for the cause then themselves.   Where is the trans gender Gandhi , Martian Luther King or Harvey Milk. No I am not asking that we search for a martyr but what we need is an example of a person that gains respect and admiration of the public while standing for the rights and supporting the lives of transgender people. In many ways we blind ourselves in thinking that Hollywood is the place to provide this answer in our world. But in fact really it shouldn’t. In many ways earlier years of trans characters and actors in some ways hurt the transgender cause. While I am a fan of, Dr. Frankenfurter from Rocky Horror, or the actor Divine’s work in John Waters films its these images along with images of Ed Woods Glenn or Glennda that manipulate the public view of transgender people. We distort the public mind set and hurt the cause in many ways with these great moments.  In many ways we need to repair the image that Hollywood helped destroy a few years ago. This repair will take time and in the mean time we need to find and hold up those that are trans that do positive things in the world not just for other trans people, not just for themselves but for the world in whole. It’s a concept that I try to carry in my own life to be a better person not for just myself but how the image I leave behind of myself be it world changing or just change a few people down the line that makes a difference not 
because I need to but because I want to.


We shouldn’t look at fame as a reason to like people cause generally with fame come ego. What we need is fame built on Humility.